24 Middagh

Historic Elegance Meets Thoughtful Innovation at 24 Middagh Street

Welcome to 24 Middagh Street, a masterfully restored Federal-style home tucked into the heart of Brooklyn Heights. One of the neighborhood’s oldest residences—originally built between 1790 and 1829—this corner property has undergone a meticulous two-year transformation. The result is a rare blend of historic preservation and modern design, offering privacy, parking, and timeless character in one of Brooklyn’s most coveted enclaves.

Located at the corner of Middagh and Willow Streets, you're steps from the Promenade, Brooklyn Bridge Park, and an easy commute into Manhattan. The property includes a 24-foot-wide, four-story main house and a separate rear carriage house, joined by a tranquil courtyard—complete with private parking, a curbcut, and an EV charger, an exceptional feature in this landmarked neighborhood.

The Main Residence

Spanning approx. $3,357 square feet across four levels, the main house features 4 bedrooms, 4.5 bathrooms, two offices, a music room, and a playroom. A 162-square-foot extension was added at the garden level, replacing a former terrace above the cellar, and expanding the main floor’s open flow between kitchen, dining, and living spaces.

A standout design feature is the entirely new custom staircase crafted by New York Stairs—a sculptural centerpiece and literal work of art that rises through the home’s core. The bathrooms throughout the house showcase thoughtful architectural curves and arched transitions, paired with handmade tile and refined finishes that create a serene, spa-like ambiance.

The renovation preserved the original shell but included a comprehensive structural overhaul: sistered joists, reinforced wood-framed walls, and steel beams throughout. A new steel portico opens the home to the courtyard, and the roof beams were fully replaced and reinforced, with a dropped ceiling added to discreetly house mechanical systems.

The Kitchen

At the heart of the home is a truly chef-worthy kitchen, with custom millwork cabinetry, a JennAir refrigerator, Miele induction cooktop, Bosch oven, and a dramatic Calacatta Viola marble countertop sourced from ABC Stone. A massive prep island and walk-in pantry complete the space—perfect for entertaining or everyday living.

The Basement

Below, the formerly unusable cellar was converted into a fully habitable basement with a concrete slab and micro-topping finish, ideal for a home gym, media room, or additional storage.

Comfort Meets Technology

Heating and cooling are managed by a completely new HVAC system, zoned across seven separate areas of the house for personalized comfort. The system is fully integrated with Google Nest Smart Home thermostats, allowing you to control the temperature of each zone remotely or via voice command. Discreet split-system units serve both the main house and carriage house, with outdoor equipment tucked away in the courtyard to preserve the home’s historic appearance. A high-efficiency ERV (Energy Recovery Ventilation) system circulates fresh air year-round without the need to open windows.

Walls were treated with air-tight membranes to reduce air leakage, and the exterior was kept entirely in wood to avoid thermal breaks.

Architectural Integrity

All windows throughout the property were replaced with high-quality double-hung wood-frame models, carefully selected to preserve the original aesthetic while improving energy performance. A restored fireplace in the living rooma dds warmth and authenticity. A large section of the Willow Street sidewalk was also rebuilt as part of the extensive exterior renovation.

Courtyard & Craftsmanship

The courtyard has been completely repaved and leveled, serving as both a peaceful outdoor haven and a functional space with direct driveway access. The handcrafted Alaskan Clear Cedar gate, inspired by century-old photos of the home, offers lasting beauty and architectural consistency.

A new drainage system of linear and point drains—tied into the city sewer—was installed around the property to protect the foundation and manage water runoff.

The Carriage House

Behind the main home, the 900-square-foot carriage house offers 2 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, a wood-burning fireplace, and its own split-system HVAC—perfect for guests, a studio, or private office space.

…

24 Middagh Street is more than just a home—it's a Brooklyn Heights landmark, revived with care and purpose. With 24 feet of width, two distinct dwellings, private parking, handcrafted details, and a one-of-a-kind blend of history, innovation, and beauty, this is one of the most compelling offerings in the city today.